‘Agatha All Along’ season 2 possible, but Marvel exec says ‘Don’t rush it'”

Marvel fans eager for more witchy mischief after Agatha All Along may have spotted a viral tweet claiming that a second season is officially confirmed—but not so fast. Despite the buzz, Marvel Studios has not confirmed a second season of the Disney+ series just yet.

The confusion started when a tweet circulated shortly stating that season 2 was “confirmed.” However, that tweet appears to be premature or speculative at best. In a February interview with Entertainment Weekly, Marvel Studios’ exec Brad Winderbaum cautiously clarified.

“Yes, a second season for sure is something that we would want to do. But let’s not rush it. Let’s get the right idea and then make it.”

So Marvel is open to continuing the story of Agatha Harkness, but nothing is currently in production or officially confirmed. Instead, Marvel appears to be taking a “wait and see” approach.

Was Agatha All Along season 1 successful?

As far as ratings, Agatha All Along season 1 was a mixed bag at best, particularly by recent standards. The series debuted on Disney+ on September 18, 2024, and quickly drew attention with 9.3 million global views in its first week and over 2.2 billion minutes streamed across its nine-episode run. Nielsen data showed 426 million minutes viewed during premiere week alone, and viewership spiked significantly with the finale—episode 8 reached 4.6 million views in a single day.

Critically, the show earned strong scores: 84% on Rotten Tomatoes from critics, an 83% audience rating, and a 7.1/10 score on Metacritic. Episode 7 was especially well-received, earning a 9.2 rating on IMDb. While it may not have matched the total watch time of Marvel’s biggest streaming hits, Agatha All Along resonated with fans and critics alike.

A measured approach to Marvel television

Overall, Winderbaum’s comments also reflect a broader shift in Marvel’s television strategy. After a crowded release schedule in 2021 and 2022, the studio is now scaling back to focus on quality over quantity. The emphasis is on well-developed narratives rather than rushing to churn out multiple seasons or spin-offs.

By stating “let’s not rush it,” Winderbaum signals that Marvel wants any future seasons of Agatha All Along to feel organic and story-driven, not just a reaction to hype.